Stillwater Twp. Homes under $500,000

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Stillwater Twp. and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Stillwater Twp. Homes under $500,000

$299,800

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Bring your vision to this late-1800s Stillwater home, featuring an entry foyer with closet, original wide-plank wood floors, three levels, and a flexible three-to-four-bedroom layout. Set on approximately one-third acre, the property offers side yards on both sides of the house and wooded views from the expansive 25 x 38 foot deck. The home awaits updates and improvements, to bring it to its full potential. A wood-burning stove was previously installed, offering the possibility for reinstallation should you desire to resurrect the appearance of the late Victorian era.Enjoy Stillwater?s scenic countryside, historic charm, and outdoor recreation. Swartswood State Park offers kayaking, canoeing, sailing, fishing, seasonal swimming, and trails for hiking and biking, adding to the appeal of life in this picturesque Sussex County community. An opportunity to restore a home with character and make it your own. Recent updates include the roof on the main portion of the house, oil burner, Roth tank and well pump.The slab and two foundation walls remain from a former garage with an apartment above, providing a blank canvas for your ideas. Buyers are encouraged to explore the possibilities and verify how their vision for this property can become a reality.

929 Wall St, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Contact: 973-727-7626

$369,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Discover the best of country living at 925 Wall Street, where a beautifully updated home and the natural beauty of Stillwater Township come together. Set on .63 acres along a quiet country road, this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath Colonial welcomes you with a bright interior and a renovated kitchen featuring granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and ample cabinetry. Two updated full baths, central air and heat, thoughtful improvements throughout, and a one-car garage offer the comfort and convenience today's buyers are looking for. Outside, the setting is part of the experience. Gather around the fire pit on crisp evenings, relax and enjoy the peaceful surroundings, or head out to experience the outdoor recreation that makes this corner of Sussex County so special. Spend weekends hiking, fishing, kayaking, boating or exploring nearby Swartswood State Park, area lakes and trails, and the Delaware Water Gap. From summer days on the water and spectacular fall foliage to winter hikes and spring adventures, there's something to enjoy in every season. Newton's shopping, dining and services are just a short drive away, with access to Routes 94 and 206 and connections to I-80. Move-in ready and surrounded by nature, 925 Wall Street offers more than a home it's an opportunity to embrace a quieter pace, outdoor adventure and the Northwest New Jersey lifestyle.

925 Wall St, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY, Contact: 973-726-0088

$290,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Have you always wanted to live in a log cabin, in the woods? Now's your chance. Come experience the charm of log cabin living. Welcome to this pristine 2-bedroom home, where rustic character meets comfortable living. Built in 1940, this log cabin has been preserved & meticulously maintained. The warmth and natural beauty of the log construction create a cozy retreat that feels like home the moment you walk in the door. The recent addition of a second bedroom expands living space. Enjoy the cozy loft. A pristine stone fireplace with a woodburning insert provides warmth on chilly evenings. The large deck extends living outdoors & provides the chance to soak in nature. It's located in desirable the Paulinskill Lake Community, where residents enjoy fishing, boating, beaches, playgrounds & trails. with a state park and great restaurants are nearby. This inviting property offers the perfect setting for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying a peaceful escape from daily life. And you'll appreciate the low taxes. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or investment opportunity, this unique cabin offers plenty of character and many possibilities.

928 Cedar Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY, Contact: 973-726-0088

$437,500

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Enjoy comfortable one-level living in this ranch at 979 Owassa Road in Newton, set on approximately half an acre a generous property made up of three combined lots, offering space that's uncommon in a lake community. The thoughtfully arranged layout places the spacious primary suite at one end of the home and two additional bedrooms at the opposite end. Added in 2004, the primary suite features an en suite bath and walk-in closet. The dining room with pellet stove opens onto the back deck and a fenced portion of the yard, with room to expand the enclosed area for outdoor enjoyment. The front study includes a wood burning fireplace (condition to be assessed by buyer) Practical features include leaf guards on the gutters, basement and addition include French drains, and a Roth oil tank. An active solar lease helps significantly reduce electricity costs. Homeowners also have the option to join Plymouth Lake and enjoy its amenities, with membership voluntary at this address. With a spacious lot, a private primary retreat, and inviting outdoor space, this home offers a comfortable setting to make your own.

979 Owassa Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY, Contact: 973-726-0088

$389,000

3 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Move-in ready and full of charm, this updated 3-bedroom, 1-bath ranch in Stillwater Township?s Paulinskill Lake community offers peaceful Sussex County living with lake amenities! An inviting open floor plan connects the sun-filled living room with an updated kitchen featuring quartz countertops, new cabinetry, newer appliances, a Zellige tile backsplash, and an island with breakfast bar and storage. Refinished hardwood floors in the living and dining rooms complement new hardwood flooring in the kitchen and all three bedrooms. Improvements include a freshly painted exterior, a new primary bedroom window, and septic system updates. A spacious laundry/mudroom, pellet stove, and one-car garage add everyday convenience. Sliding doors open to a back deck overlooking a generous private yard, with plenty of outdoor space for gardening, entertaining, or simply enjoying the peace and quiet. Enjoy access to Paulinskill Lake community amenities, including swimming, fishing, boating, pickleball, basketball, tennis, picnic areas, and a playground. Less than 10 minutes from Newton, this updated Stillwater, ranch blends single-level comfort, outdoor recreation, and lake community living. Photos have been brightened.

916 Cedar Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX PLATINUM GROUP, Contact: 973-726-5700

$375,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

LAKEFRONT LIVING! Enjoy panoramic open-water views and direct lake access from this beautifully updated, move-in-ready waterfront home. Major improvements include a new septic system installed in 2020, roof just 4 years old, upgraded 200-amp electrical panel, fresh interior paint, and newer flooring throughout. The updated kitchen with newer appliances opens to the living room, where exposed wood beams, high ceilings, and an inviting fireplace create a warm, welcoming space. Step outside onto the spacious entertaining deck overlooking the water and imagine starting each morning with lake views right from your dining room. Upstairs, the bedroom has lake views and features skylights that bring in tons of natural light and enhance the airy feel. Your private lakefront frontage offers direct access for launching canoes and kayaks, plus a dedicated lakeside fire pit area perfect for relaxing by the water. A large, fully concreted basement, conveniently accessed from the side of the home offers clean and practical storage for seasonal gear and lake toys. Enjoy the clubhouse, the beach, hiking, fishing, kayaking & Boating (Electric motors only), Outdoor living at its best. When you're ready to explore beyond your backyard, enjoy nearby outdoor destinations including the Delaware Water Gap, White Lake Natural Resource Area, and Swartswood State Park. Move right in and start enjoying the lakefront lifestyle from day one!

907 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of COMPASS NEW JERSEY, LLC, Contact: 862-281-2653

$499,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

LAKEFRONT living on beautiful Lake Plymouth! Nestled beneath mature trees in peaceful Stillwater Township, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath lake-style colonial home offers the kind of setting that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Inside, exposed beams and a cozy fireplace add warmth and character, but it's the beautiful lake views from the dining room that truly steal the show. Open the windows and enjoy the refreshing breezes coming off the lake as you dine, relax or entertain with the water as your backdrop. Multiple living spaces provide plenty of room to gather, while the primary bedroom is privately located on the second floor, separate from the two main-level bedrooms. Outside, the deck, patio and lakefront yard invite you to enjoy morning coffee, summer barbecues, quiet afternoons and evenings by the water. Even better, two major improvements are already complete with a NEW ROOF AND NEW SIDING JUNE 2026, along with a NEW RANGE AND NEW REFRIGERATOR DECEMBER 2025. With approximately .34 acre of lakefront property, this is a special opportunity to enjoy the beauty, tranquility and lifestyle of Lake Plymouth while adding your own style along the way. Buyer to independently verify all association fees and related costs. Some pictures have been rendered with AI for visual and illustration purposes ONLY!!!

915 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX PLATINUM GROUP, Contact: 973-726-5700

$425,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

If living in the country in your own special spot is something you've been wanting, look no further! This adorable 2-bedroom, 2-full-bath home offers a wonderful opportunity for a weekend getaway or a peaceful place to call home. Enjoy a spacious great room with double doors that open onto the deck, creating an easy connection between indoor and outdoor living. A separate entrance into the kitchen and laundry area adds extra convenience after a day spent enjoying the outdoors. Step onto the back deck and take in the quiet, wooded surroundings and the beauty of the forest just beyond your door. The property is adjacent to a picturesque horse farm, adding beautiful pastoral scenery to this special country setting. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or a place to escape and unwind, this charming home offers plenty of possibilities. Property is being sold strictly AS-IS. Seller will make no repairs or concessions. Seller is not aware of any known defects.

927 Owassa Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX SUPREME, Contact: 908-581-5241

$299,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

SELLER TO INSTALL BRAND-NEW SEPTIC PRIOR TO CLOSING (OR OPTION FOR $260,000 AS-IS WITHOUT SEPTIC)! Property is sold strict AS-IS except for a brand-new, town-approved septic installed at seller's expense prior to closing. Back on market due to failure to reach agreement during inspection. Outstanding opportunity in desirable Crandon Lakes with access through Timber Lane! This move-in ready 2-bedroom ranch features upgrades, including new roof shingles, new wood fence and new above-ground oil tank. Bright interior with a clean layout, dining area, deck, and private yard for outdoor living. Brand-new septic makes this home fully eligible for conventional and FHA financing. Complete Lake Community package!

901 Chestnut Path, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY, Contact: 973-726-0088

$419,900

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths

Step back in time and fall in love with this enchanting circa-1780 Colonial, where nearly 250 years of history meet modern comfort. Nestled on 1.9 picturesque acres, located in the Stillwater Township School District, this storybook property offers a peaceful escape surrounded by nature. Inside, timeless details abound, including wide-plank wood floors, bluestone flooring, original wood doors, exposed stone walls, hand-hewn beams, crown molding, two fireplaces, and a cozy wood stove. The country kitchen opens to a sunny dining area with easy access to the beautiful grounds. Upstairs, the stunning primary bedroom is anchored by a dramatic floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, while a second bedroom, updated full bath, and versatile den provide flexible living space. Sip your morning coffee on the covered rocking chair porch, unwind around the built-in fire pit, and enjoy the privacy and beauty of the expansive property. Complete with newer Hardie Plank siding and a detached garage, this treasured home featured on the 2013 Local Home Tour is a rare opportunity to own a piece of local history and create the next chapter of its remarkable story.

919 Wall St, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS PREMIER, Contact: 609-638-3723

$399,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Investor's dream in the desirable Stillwater section of Newton! This income-producing two-family property offers the perfect opportunity for investors or owner-occupants looking to offset their mortgage with rental income.Each unit is serviced by its own private driveway, separate boiler, and separate oil tank, providing added convenience and reducing shared maintenance concerns. A newer roof helps minimize future expenses and adds peace of mind for years to come.Situated in a sought-after location with easy access to local amenities, shopping, dining, and major roadways, this property combines privacy, functionality, and strong investment potential. Whether you're building your portfolio or searching for a multi-family property with excellent long-term value, this is an opportunity you won't want to miss.Strong rental potential, separate utilities, and a great location make this one a must-see.

1068 County Road 521, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX SELECT, Contact: 973-625-0450

$320,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths

Lake Community Living at Its Finest! Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home in the desirable Paulinskill Lake community of Newton Township. Perfect as a full-time residence or a peaceful weekend getaway, this home offers comfort, charm, and a true lake-lifestyle setting. Perched on a hill with a welcoming front entry, the home opens to a foyer leading into an expansive living room featuring a cozy wood-burning stove. The modern eat-in kitchen boasts shaker-style cabinetry, quartz countertops, subway tile backsplash, and an open flow into the dining area, ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Additional features include in-unit laundry, a spacious den, and a bedroom suite with its own en-suite bath. Step outside to a tranquil backyard with a large wooden deck, perfect for relaxing, hosting, or enjoying the natural surroundings. Newer septic installed in 2024. A rare opportunity to enjoy updated living in a beautiful lake community!

912 E Walnut Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Contact: 347-579-9277

Start Your Search

board logo The data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Century 21 AG Realty Group are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: . Source: New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. “2026 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.”

Stillwater Twp. Homes under $500,000

Newest Stillwater Twp. Homes under $500,000

How much is your home worth?

How much is your home worth?