Stillwater Twp. Homes for Sale

Stillwater Twp. Homes for Sale

Welcome to Stillwater Township, located in Sussex County, New Jersey. This charming township offers a perfect blend of rural tranquility and modern convenience, making it an ideal place to call home. With its picturesque landscapes and friendly community atmosphere, Stillwater Township provides residents with a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life.

For those looking to make a move to this serene area, there are plenty of homes for sale in Stillwater Township. Whether you're in the market for a cozy cottage, a spacious family home, or a secluded retreat, you'll find a variety of options to suit your needs and preferences. From historic properties with character to newly built houses with modern amenities, there is something for everyone in Stillwater Township.

Imagine waking up to the sounds of nature, taking a leisurely stroll through the scenic countryside, and enjoying the stunning views of the surrounding hills and forests. In Stillwater Township, you can experience all this and more while still being just a short drive away from shopping, dining, and entertainment options.

If you're ready to make a move to a place where community spirit thrives and natural beauty abounds, consider exploring the homes for sale in Stillwater Township. Your dream home in this idyllic setting may be just a click away.

Newest Stillwater Twp. Homes for Sale

$699,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2.1 Baths

986 Fairview Lake Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of BHGRE GREEN TEAM, Contact: 973-476-0878

$275,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
LOW TAXES, MOVE-IN READY, EXTENSIVELY RENOVATED! This 2-bedroom, 1-bath log cabin in Paulinskill Lake is a great alternative to renting, perfect for anyone looking to downsize, or could even be a 2nd home for anyone looking to get out on the water without breaking the bank. Recent updates include new flooring (2026), new deck with privacy screen (2026), new refrigerator (2026), renovated bathroom with new tile shower (2025), new washer/dryer (2025), mini-split heating & cooling (2025), new dishwasher (2025), and new gutters (2024). Newer gas range and microwave (2022). Enjoy a large, private backyard, new deck, a pellet stove that heats the entire home in the cold months, and a mini split AC system that efficiently keeps the house cool in the summer. Low property taxes, extensive updates, and move-in-ready condition make this an affordable, low-maintenance home with plenty of charm. Come see it today!

929 Cedar Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of ADDISON REAL ESTATE, Contact: 862-251-4915

$539,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
LAKEFRONT living on beautiful Lake Plymouth! Nestled beneath mature trees in peaceful Stillwater Township, this charming 3-bedroom, 2-bath lake-style colonial home offers the kind of setting that makes you want to slow down and stay awhile. Inside, exposed beams and a cozy fireplace add warmth and character, but it's the beautiful lake views from the dining room that truly steal the show. Open the windows and enjoy the refreshing breezes coming off the lake as you dine, relax or entertain with the water as your backdrop. Multiple living spaces provide plenty of room to gather, while the primary bedroom is privately located on the second floor, separate from the two main-level bedrooms. Outside, the deck, patio and lakefront yard invite you to enjoy morning coffee, summer barbecues, quiet afternoons and evenings by the water. Even better, two major improvements are already complete with a NEW ROOF AND NEW SIDING JUNE 2026, along with a NEW RANGE AND NEW REFRIGERATOR DECEMBER 2025. With approximately .34 acre of lakefront property, this is a special opportunity to enjoy the beauty, tranquility and lifestyle of Lake Plymouth while adding your own style along the way. Buyer to independently verify all association fees and related costs. Some pictures have been rendered with AI for visual and illustrations purposes ONLY!!!

915 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX PLATINUM GROUP, Contact: 973-726-5700

$425,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
If living in the country in your own special spot is something you've been wanting, look no further! This adorable 2-bedroom, 2-full-bath home offers a wonderful opportunity for a weekend getaway or a peaceful place to call home. Enjoy a spacious great room with double doors that open onto the deck, creating an easy connection between indoor and outdoor living. A separate entrance into the kitchen and laundry area adds extra convenience after a day spent enjoying the outdoors. Step onto the back deck and take in the quiet, wooded surroundings and the beauty of the forest just beyond your door. The property is adjacent to a picturesque horse farm, adding beautiful pastoral scenery to this special country setting. Whether you're looking for a full-time residence or a place to escape and unwind, this charming home offers plenty of possibilities. Property is being sold strictly AS-IS. Seller will make no repairs or concessions. Seller is not aware of any known defects.

927 Owassa Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX SUPREME, Contact: 908-581-5241

$385,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Escape the city heat at 907 Plymouth Lake Drive, a beautifully refreshed 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom lakefront property nestled in the hills of Stillwater Township. Step inside to an inviting interior where an updated kitchen and updated bathroom take center stage alongside cathedral ceilings, bright skylights, a cozy fireplace, fresh paint, and gorgeous floors. Open the doors to a spacious entertaining deck directly overlooking the open water, offering panoramic lake views. Your private lakefront frontage provides an ideal launch point for canoes or kayaks right at the water's edge, plus a dedicated area for a lakeside fire pit. This turn-key home offers true peace of mind with excellent structural integrity, featuring added structural beams for enhanced stability and long-term security. Additional major upgrades include a new septic system (2020), a premium architectural roof 4 years old and an upgraded 200-amp electrical panel. Storage is a major plus here, as a large, fully concreted crawl space provides a clean, solid, and reliable area to safely keep your seasonal gear and lake toys. Beyond the property, an active lifestyle awaits just minutes away. Explore the scenic vistas of the Delaware Water Gap, kayak through White Lake Natural Resource Area, or hike Swartswood State Park. Residents also enjoy a free community pool and rich local charm. This is the ultimate waterfront retreat.

907 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of COMPASS NEW JERSEY, LLC, Contact: 862-281-2653

$510,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
If you value your privacy, visit this Country Home shielded from the street by a stand of mature trees, a short walk from Swartswood Lake. This secluded retreat on 1.6 acres offers 2,742 square ft. of living space with 3 large bedrooms and 2 full baths. The Dining Room is conveniently located next to the Kitchen and leads to a deck overlooking your private garden. Downstairs you will find a spacious 23' Family- Room warmed by a woodburning stove. Also on this level is the Laundry Room. For those who work from home there is a large Home Office also on this level, which provides a lot of privacy from the busy activities of " home life" upstairs. From this private office you can take a short walk to the two Car Garage with a HEATED WORKSHOP upstairs, this is your own private world seperated from the daily activities of the home., a quiet place to work on personal projects in the peace of the garden. Swartswood Lake is a short walk from this home. If you enjoy taking long walks on the trails or fishing at the lake, you might consider visiting this home.

903 Dove Island Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of RE/MAX HERITAGE PROPERTIES, Contact: 973-598-1700

$445,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Easy one floor living in this expanded Ranch situated on nearly 3/4 acres with plenty of parking for vehicles and/or RV/Boat/etc. NEW septic in process of being installed! Newer roof! Large country Kitchen with ample counter space and cabinetry. A custom handcrafted mantle and surround with built-ins flank the fireplace in the Living Room. The main living area is flooded with natural light that flows in through the sliders that lead to a ground level patio. The fenced in backyard is the perfect spot for outdoor entertaining with the built-in BBQ, patio and pergola. Back indoors you'll find 3 bedrooms including a Primary with direct access to the backyard and a private ensuite. Hardwood floors throughout. Central Air! Paulinskil Lake Association offers multiple, Member Only beaches, Tennis/Basketball courts, picnic area as well as many community actives. Fishing, boating, kayaking...create YOUR lake life! Weather you're just starting out, downsizing or anything in-between, this home has plenty of space and a great yard!

958 Cedar Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of REALTY EXECUTIVES EXCEPTIONAL, Contact: 973-417-0079

$3,295,000
6 Beds ⋅ 6.1 Baths
You cannot see Dove Island from the road. You may have already seen it in print. 40+ private acres in Sussex County, published in Great Houses & Gardens of New Jersey, held by one family since 1968, on land first farmed by the Westbrook family, among the earliest pioneers of this frontier. The 1890 farmhouse grew into a roughly 10,000 sq ft residence, redesigned by a Sag Harbor firm known for Hamptons estates. Stone, hand forged iron & deep wood run through the rooms. The two story great room rises around a monumental stone fireplace under a library that wraps the full second floor, & the kitchen is anchored by a cast iron British Aga. Down a gallery hall of lit museum cases sits a 19th century walnut paneled boardroom, dismantled on Wall Street & rebuilt here piece by piece. The primary suite holds dual dressing rooms, a fireplace sitting room & a spiral iron staircase to a hidden solarium under the primary bedroom. Beyond, a heated gunite pool & stone patios, a full pool house, tennis court, dual greenhouses, pond w/ bass, carp, catfish & koi, plus a climate controlled iron barn built to hold cars & collections. Multiple buildings & full generator infrastructure keep it running. The original farmland is ready for pasture, orchard or whatever comes next, w/ miles of equestrian & hiking trails close by. Estates like this are not built anymore. Multiple lots included. Shown by appointment only. Not currently farm assessed but can be, for significant savings.

936 Dove Island Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS INTEGRITY, Contact: 973-726-0088

$419,900
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Step back in time and fall in love with this enchanting circa-1780 Colonial, where nearly 250 years of history meet modern comfort. Nestled on 1.9 picturesque acres, located in the Stillwater Township School District, this storybook property offers a peaceful escape surrounded by nature. Inside, timeless details abound, including wide-plank wood floors, bluestone flooring, original wood doors, exposed stone walls, hand-hewn beams, crown molding, two fireplaces, and a cozy wood stove. The country kitchen opens to a sunny dining area with easy access to the beautiful grounds. Upstairs, the stunning primary bedroom is anchored by a dramatic floor-to-ceiling stone fireplace, while a second bedroom, updated full bath, and versatile den provide flexible living space. Sip your morning coffee on the covered rocking chair porch, unwind around the built-in fire pit, and enjoy the privacy and beauty of the expansive property. Complete with newer Hardie Plank siding and a detached garage, this treasured home featured on the 2013 Local Home Tour is a rare opportunity to own a piece of local history and create the next chapter of its remarkable story.

919 Wall St, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of KELLER WILLIAMS PREMIER, Contact: 609-638-3723

$568,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths
Lakefront Living at Its Finest on Paulinskill Lake. Wake up to breathtaking lake views and experience the feeling of being on vacation every day in this beautifully restored lakefront retreat on Paulinskill Lake. Whether you're looking for a year-round residence or the perfect weekend escape, this charming two-bedroom, one-bath home offers timeless character with modern updates.Originally restored in 2004, this exceptional home showcases stunning original Craftsman details, including hand-carved beams, built-in bookcases, original windows, and a magnificent stone fireplace that serves as the heart of the home.Step inside to discover a bright, open-concept floor plan featuring a granite kitchen with a skylight, center island for meal prep and entertaining, and seamless flow into the formal dining and living rooms. The living room is filled with natural light from dramatic floor-to-ceiling windows and sliding glass doors that open onto a spacious deck overlooking the water.Outdoor living is just as impressive, with multiple decks, a private lower-level patio, and a custom stone outdoor kitchen perfect for entertaining family and friends while enjoying spectacular lake views.Enjoy everything Paulinskill Lake has to offer, including boating, swimming, fishing, sandy beaches, playgrounds, and a welcoming lake community. Don't miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of lakefront paradise. Schedule your private showing today!

904 E End Rd, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of REALTY EXECUTIVES EXCEPTIONAL, Contact: 201-486-7045

$599,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
LAKEFRONT LIVING AT ITS FINEST! Welcome to this beautifully renovated waterfront retreat on desirable Plymouth Lake, offering breathtaking sunset views, your own private beach, firepit, and year-round vacation-style living. This exceptional home features 3 bedrooms with a 4-bedroom septic, including two spacious lakefront suites with private balconies overlooking the water. The open-concept layout is designed to maximize lake views from nearly every room, while recent upgrades elevate the home throughout, including stunning 6 rift and quartered solid white oak flooring, updated kitchen with stone counters and backsplash, new appliances, fresh paint, and upgraded lighting. Stay comfortable year-round with a newly installed ducted mini-split system, and enjoy cozy evenings by the stone fireplace with pellet stove. Step outside to an expansive deck, brand-new hot tub with gazebo, basketball hoop, and beautifully designed outdoor spaces perfect for entertaining or relaxing lakeside. Additional features include an oversized detached 2-car garage with large floored upper storage area, RV/electric vehicle hookup, generator hookup, upgraded electric panel, exterior camera system, and included boats for endless lake adventures. Located near hiking trails, the Appalachian Trail, shopping, and local attractions. Your lakefront escape awaits!

931 Plymouth Lake Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Contact: 973-536-8554

$320,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Lake Community Living at Its Finest! Welcome to this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home in the desirable Paulinskill Lake community of Newton Township. Perfect as a full-time residence or a peaceful weekend getaway, this home offers comfort, charm, and a true lake-lifestyle setting. Perched on a hill with a welcoming front entry, the home opens to a foyer leading into an expansive living room featuring a cozy wood-burning stove. The modern eat-in kitchen boasts shaker-style cabinetry, quartz countertops, subway tile backsplash, and an open flow into the dining area, ideal for everyday living and entertaining. Additional features include in-unit laundry, a spacious den, and a bedroom suite with its own en-suite bath. Step outside to a tranquil backyard with a large wooden deck, perfect for relaxing, hosting, or enjoying the natural surroundings. Newer septic installed in 2024. A rare opportunity to enjoy updated living in a beautiful lake community!

912 E Walnut Dr, Stillwater Twp.

Listing Courtesy Of COLDWELL BANKER REALTY, Contact: 347-579-9277

Start Your Search

board logoThe data relating to the real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange Program of the NJMLS. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Century 21 AG Realty Group are marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. Some properties listed with the participating brokers do not appear on this website at the request of the seller. Listings of brokers that do not participate in Internet Data Exchange do not appear on this website. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. Last date updated: . Source: New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. “2026 New Jersey Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.”